Capital Punishment: Does Race Matter?.
The employment of the death penalty as the ultimate criminal sanction has been the subject of enormous debate both in the United States and internationally. Execution has been challenged not only on moral grounds, but on constitutional grounds. Specifically, capital punishment has been argued to violate the Eighth Amendment, which guarantees protection against cruel and unusual punishment. The Supreme Court held in Furman v. Georgia (1972) that the arbitrary nature of the death penalty system was in violation of the Eighth amendment, and ordered states to rework their sentencing procedures. Justice Thurgood Marshall identified racial discrimination based both on the race of the defendant and the race of the victim, as the primary reason he joined the Supreme Court's majority decision in the Furman case. He was one of several justices who found that racial discrimination produced different patterns of sentencing and rates of execution for blacks and whites. ( Rothman, p.1)The Court's subsequent ruling in Gregg v. Georgia (1976) required judges and juries to use "guided discretion" when implementing capital sentences in an effort to combat arbitrariness, consequently reinstating the death penalty. Now, in the post-Furman death penalty era the question remains " does race matter in capital punishment cases, either the race of the victim or the defendant?" Based on and despite the efforts of Gregg v. Georgia (1976) to eradicate the arbitrary nature of the Capital Punishment system, race continues to influence procedures in prosecuting, sentencing, and administering capital punishment, thus violating the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution. .
There is a long history of racial discrimination in the implementation of capital punishment in this country. "In 1848, for example, Virginia enacted a statute which required Blacks to be executed for any crime for which Whites might receive three years imprisonment.
It stands for the total abolition of the death penalty but allows states parties to retain the death penalty in time of war. ... Some states have already abolished the death penalty. ... Some people think the death penalty is fair. ... The death penalty is a global issue. ... The death penalty isn't a way to prevent crime. ...
Currently, there have been over 1,000 deaths due to the death penalty since 1976 (Death Penalty Information Center). ... There are many different forms of execution used in the death penalty. ... Three years later in 2009, New Mexico repealed the death penalty. ... The death penalty gives most people a sense of security in many states. ... The Catholic religion is the religion most against the death penalty. ...
I am against the death penalty. ... "A new survey by the New York Times found that states without the death penalty have lower homicide rates than states with the death penalty" ("Facts" 6). ... My last reason for my opposition to the death penalty is its constitutionality, whether or not the death penalty should be legal. ... "The Death Penalty on Trial." ... "Debating the Death Penalty." ...
The Old Testament clearly calls for the death penalty on many occasions. ... In the case of the death penalty, an individual kills another human being and he is punished for it by death. ... Statistics from the Death Penalty Information Center (1997) show that the death penalty does not really deter crime. When comparisons are made between states with the death penalty and states without it, the majority of the death penalty states show murder rates higher than non-death penalty states. ... In 1996, death penalty states averaged a rate of 7.1 criminal homicides per 100,000, while non-death pen...
(Religious Organizing Against the Death Penalty Website) The main argument that advocates for the death penalty have is that the death penalty deters crime, that the threat of execution is enough to make criminals think twice about committing a capital crime. ... Clearly, by the time he has decided to commit his crime, he has already disregarded other forms of punishment besides the death penalty, such as lengthy imprisonment. ... Also, states that do not have a death penalty experience lower number of murders each year than that of the states who do. ... (Death Penalty Information Ce...
After the Supreme Court made this ruling, states reviewed their death penalty laws. ... The death penalty contradicts the whole idea of human rights. ... Supporters of the death penalty believe that the death penalty helps keep the crime and murder rate down, but that is not so. States with death penalty laws do not have lower crime or rates than states that with death penalty laws. ... If the death penalty is not "cruel and unusual punishment" then what is? ...
-Contact Death Penalty Focus. ... -Start a Death Penalty Focus chapter at your school. ... -Attend national conferences on death penalty organizing. ... What Teachers Can Do -Use the Death Penalty Information Center's curriculum for educators in your classroom! ... Death Penalty Focus can help you find many excellent speakers. ...
One way people are being deprived of their rights is the use of the death penalty. The death penalty is often used to kill people who have committed murder. ... The death penalty is not a surefire way to punish criminals. ... Jury members may avoid the death penalty for this very reason. ... If the death penalty does not deter crime, why should there have a death penalty? ...
DEATH PENALTY The death penalty has existed as long as humans have existed. ... There have been many comparisons of crime rates of death penalty states to non-death penalty states. ... Michigan, Ohio and Illinois all have the death penalty. ... In 1994, the average murder rate in death penalty states of a population of 100,00 was 8.0, for a non-death penalty state, 4.4. ... In 1976 Canada got rid of the death penalty. ...
The death penalty protects society because if the murderers are executed, they are no longer on the streets (The Death Penalty). ... Studies show that by increasing the death penalty by one percent, it would prevent one hundred and five murders (The Death Penalty). ... Why the society defends the death penalty. ... Arguments of those who oppose the death penalty. ... Concluding thoughts of reinstating the death penalty....
