(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

A Critical Examination Of Valls" Interpretation Of Just War Theory

            A Critical Examination of Valls" Interpretation of Just War Theory.
             In light of recent events and the current "war on terrorism" it seems critical to move away from political rhetoric and approach the issue with as much reasonable objectivity as possible. The central question that Andrew Valls attempts to answer is weather terrorism can be justified. He argues that it can in some cases when measured against just war theory. Just war theory sets moral limits on the waging of war while justifying its legitimacy. I am in agreement with his conclusion but my defense of his argument relies on acceptance of his definition of terrorism, which seems to me rather broad.
             Valls defines terrorism as political violence done to persons or property committed by nonstate actors. It must be politically motivated for any other form of violence is considered crime and subject to domestic laws. He adds violence against property to include attacks that would be considered terrorism even though they do not harm people. An example of this would be the bombing of an abortion clinic. When he limits the violence to nonstate actors, he doesn't deny the existence of state sponsored terrorism. He states that this type of violence is a matter of domestic justice, and in cases outside its borders, just war theory can be applied.
             With this definition he attempts to avoid two difficulties. He does not prejudge the issue by characterizing terrorism as something intrinsically wrong, which is what Walzer seems to do. How can there be serious discussion about a normative issue if it is already defined as unjustifiable? He also attempts to avoid making his definition stipulative.
             I would argue that Valls" definition is too broad with respect to his contention that it is nonessential to include fear or intimidation as a deliberate strategy of terrorism. Of course if this provision were added, it would weaken his argument by disqualifying many cases of nonstate violence.


Essays Related to A Critical Examination Of Valls" Interpretation Of Just War Theory

1. a critique of Valls' examinati

He argues that it can in some cases when measured against just war theory. Just war theory sets moral limits on the waging of war while justifying its legitimacy. ... Even if a terrorist does involve the killing of innocents, Valls contends that this does not place terrorism beyond the scope of just war theory, which only requires that noncombatants not be targeted. ... Finding examples of terrorist groups that meet the requirements of just war theory is a difficult task, as it should be. ... Using the definition Valls presents, it is clear that there are some acts of terrorism that can be...

  • Word Count: 1205
  • Approx Pages: 5
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

2. Affirmative action

Another basis for affirmative action is made by Andrew Valls. ... An example of the former would include the United States" reparations to the Japanese put in internment camps during World War II. ... Consequently, Valls" primary basis for affirmative action is not sufficient. ... The underlying theory is that those in a lower class of society have not been subjected to as much opportunity as others. ... In theory, this practice ought to help in diminishing both injustices of discrimination and unequal opportunity. ...

  • Word Count: 1569
  • Approx Pages: 6
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

3. Affirmative Action

Another basis for affirmative action is made by Andrew Valls. ... An example of the former would include the United States" reparations to the Japanese put in internment camps during World War II. ... Consequently, Valls" primary basis for affirmative action is not sufficient. ... The underlying theory is that those in a lower class of society have not been subjected to as much opportunity as others. ... In theory, this practice ought to help in diminishing both injustices of discrimination and unequal opportunity. ...

  • Word Count: 1569
  • Approx Pages: 6
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

4. Literary Theory and Teaching Literature

Keywords Twenty- first century education, poststructuralist literary theory, teaching of literature, critical pedagogy, social cognitive learning. ... It will argue that various schools of  poststructuralist literary theory such as Feminism, Marxism, New historicism, and Post-colonialism, etc., are reader –centered approaches of literary interpretation which actively involve the readers in meaning making. In this way poststructuralist literary theories have great potential for making learners critical readers and creative explorers which is the fundamental aim of 21st century pedagog...

  • Word Count: 1829
  • Approx Pages: 7
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Graduate

5. Just War Theory

Just War For more than a thousand years Christian ethicists and theologians have used the language of just war theory to determine when it is morally acceptable for a Christian to go to war. ... When asked about war some would allude to the Just War Theory. Just war theorists trace the beginnings of the theory to Augustine's idea of normative political order. ... A great impetus to the Just War Theory was St. ... The key principle underlying just cause, and just war theory more broadly, is the vindication of fundamental rights ...

  • Word Count: 7503
  • Approx Pages: 30
  • Has Bibliography

6. Four Theories (causes) of the Revolutionary War

The theories are Anglo-American crisis; economic interpretation; political interpretation and social interpretation. ... The second theory, economic interpretation, is another strong reason for the occurrence of the Revolutionary war. ... If one were to rank this theory, just as the other two have, political interpretation should receive 15 points. ... The last theory, social interpretation, is very important when referring to the Revolutionary war. ... Each of these theories played a part in the beginning of the Revolutionary war. ...

  • Word Count: 977
  • Approx Pages: 4
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

7. Critical Examination of the EAP Debate

This paper critically examines the varied approaches to teaching English for Academic Purposes (EAP). In particular, it examines Critical Pedagogy, Pragmatic Pedagogy and Critical-Pragmatic Pedagogy in the context of teaching academic writing to university students. ... Other academics argue the case of a vulgar pragmatic approach that relies on structure and 'the notions of theory and practice' (Williams: 1983). ... As an example, Brandt assesses that students of critical pragmatism 'can be taught the principles of critical review' but at the same time 'learn when ...

  • Word Count: 1625
  • Approx Pages: 7
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Graduate

8. An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution

Beard claims that Madison believes "the theories of government which men entertain are emotional reactions to their property interests" (Beard 121). ... However, Beard fails to acknowledge a critical passage from Federalist No. 10, which disclaims his statement by saying that people are, in fact, not as simple as Beard makes them seem. ... The purpose of the judicial committee is to focus on and protect the rights of numerous large groups of citizens and not just a singular person to benefit their specific interests. ... The fact that Beard left out critical parts of Federalist No. 1...

  • Word Count: 1327
  • Approx Pages: 5
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

9. Summary of Critical Thinking

Critical thinking enables one to take on an abundance of information and this is critical when working in any profession. ... The final reason critical thinking is important in the work place is because it is important for employees to pick out the theories and arguments of various information, so that the can communicate their opinion or viewpoints in an effective and scholarly manner. ... A critical society is a society of individuals who know the significance of critical thinking and value individuals who take use in it.3  A critical society is on that is constantly refining itself.  ......

  • Word Count: 969
  • Approx Pages: 4
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question