Consider an investment firm whose clientele consists solely of older white males. It may very well be in the firm's best interests to have a workforce consisting of older white males. Yet most would think it completely unjust for such a firm to give preferential treatment to a less qualified older white male over a black applicant. If diversity as a basis for affirmative action was justified, then it would have to be asymmetrical meaning that one could instead prefer a uniform distribution of race in an institution. Because this would not be acceptable, it would be wrong to label diversity and uniformity as right and wrong accordingly.
Another basis for affirmative action is made by Andrew Valls. Valls states, "Affirmative action provides a fairly low-cost way of partially satisfying the requirement to rectify the effects of past violations of rights by increasing opportunities to close the gap between black and white income"(Valls 69). In his attempt to make a libertarian case for affirmative action, Valls believes that the practice is justified based upon past injustices towards a particular group of people. His justification is also flawed, not necessarily because of its logic but rather its feasibility. Placing a value on past injustices such as slavery is not possible. This is not to say that rectifications don't come in both feasible and non-feasible forms. An example of the former would include the United States" reparations to the Japanese put in internment camps during World War II. The injustice had been fairly recent and its affects reasonably undisputable (much of it was based on loss of property). Unfortunately, rectifications for an injustice like slavery would fall into the category of the latter. One would have to research the past in an attempt to decide such queries as whom the victims and victors of the injustice were and how might their situations be different today.
Affirmative action is a question of morals. Affirmative action is a growing argument among our society. ... Is affirmative action fair? ... Well if that is a reason for affirmative action why not make it to where all children, regardless of race, who are in the poorer communities reap the benefits of affirmative action. ... Affirmative action should definitely be looked into with greater depth. ...
This compromise can also be known as a form of Affirmative Action. ... (Franz ) Even today, many states still use some shape or form of affirmative action, but affirmative action is becoming less and less popular among colleges across the nation. ... (Froomkin C6) In support of affirmative action, many people have organized groups to support their cause- keeping Affirmative Action. ... CEO, the Center for Equal Opportunity, another group that strongly supports affirmative action, takes radical views on Affirmative Action and the abilities of minorities. ... In affirmative action, it does...
The battle against affirmative action has gone so far as to halting affirmative action in places such as Missouri, and even drastically ending affirmative action in California. ... Affirmative action was organized with good intentions, however quickly many groups organized to protest affirmative action. Despite affirmative actions greatness there are intense debates. Affirmative action was ended by the foe of affirmative action, Ward Connerly. ... It is believed by the foes of affirmative action that affirmative action allowed unqualified minorities admission into the best Universities in...
It's Time To Redefine Affirmative Action Presidents and citizens of the United States have debated affirmative action for the past forty years. ... Affirmative action has infiltrated our society and in some way influences everyone. ... Bill Clinton has no doubt affirmative action has worked, but since there is still discrimination there should still be affirmative action (7). ... Affirmative action is reverse discrimination against whites. ... Affirmative action has worn out its welcome in many communities. ...
Affirmative action supporters make one large assumption when defending the policy. ... But, that is exactly what affirmative action does. ... These stunning facts shows just how many competent, if not gifted students fall between the cracks as a direct result of affirmative action (Affirmative action). ... Works Cited "Affirmative Action at the University of California at Berkeley" Online. ... Affirmative Action in the 1980's: Dismantling the Process of Discrimination. ...
Affirmative Action Animosity Affirmative action is the U.S. program set forth in the early 1970's to correct the effects of past discrimination by giving preferential treatment to women and ethnic minorities in the workplace. At the time of affirmative action's induction to society, proponents of affirmative action programs felt that the only way to increase the number of minorities in the workplace was to establish a system of quotas to be maintained by law. ... Affirmative action has created numerous opportunities for women and minorities in this country. ... Affirmative action mus...
Affirmative Action Affirmative Action efforts were started in 1964 to end the long history of overlooking qualified people of color and women from higher education. ... However, Affirmative action is highly controversial. ... The law will start slowly first, ending Affirmative Action in the schools of California, leading up to the abolishment of Affirmative Action all together. ... Abolishing Affirmative Action is not the answer. ... Affirmative Action gave Ellis a chance he would not have gotten if Affirmative Action did not exist. ...
The Pitfalls of Affirmative Action "I want to be the minority. ... The roots of affirmative action can be traced to the mid--nineteenth century. ... In addition, affirmative action often rewards minority individuals as an indirect consequence of affirmative action. ... As a result, affirmative action may provide a sense of self- doubt, rejection, and inferiority among racial and gender specific minorities, who benefit as a result of affirmative action. ... Affirmative action has always been an aberration from our lost principles. ...
