Have you ever wondered why many criminals find a higher power while being incarcerated? Is it because they want to change their lives? Or is it because they want an early release? Research shows that spiritual programs benefit some inmates because they receive fewer disciplinary reports than inmates who do no attend religious services (Gingerich, 1). .
Some believe that the faith-based program is too new to be seen as a success. For example, Department of Corrections Secretary Michael Moore said "Studies show two-thirds of inmates who do not receive structured counseling, in particular addiction treatment, will commit new crimes after they are released" (Gingerich, 1). He says this particularly about drug treatment (Chachere, 3). Inmates that go through structure programs receive substance abuse treatment, and they are released (Chachere, 3). Prison officials say recidivism rates are reduced to one in four (Chachere, 3).
In addition to some not exactly seeing this as a success, also others oppose to the promotion of faith-based programs. The ACLU of Louisiana believes that faith-based programs in correctional institutions have the potential to help some prisoners turn their lives around (Perkins, 1). But, it believes that the evaluation of recidivism rates is meaningless if only some programs are included (Perkins, 1). They believe recidivism should be measured for all programs and for all self-selected control groups whose individuals do not participate in any program (Perkins, 1). "This provision can be interpreted as requiring the state to actively recruit persons to run faith-based programs, which is impermissible under the First Amendment. By singling out religious programs this bill would result in unwise and unconstitutional entanglement of the state with religion" (Perkins, 1). Ultimately, they feel that all prison programs must be treated equally, and they feel faith-based programs requires the state to actively support religious programs (Perkins, 2).