In, "A River Runs Through It," by Norman Maclean, the main character, Norman, begins his journey in life trapped within the cocoon of speculation. Gradually, his life experiences enable him to gain the strength to emerge as a butterfly of grace and beauty. Confined within the margins of speculation, Norman did not begin life as smoothly as his brother; he scrutinized every instance. This is initially exemplified as he recants his father's belief that, "Man by nature was a mess and had fallen from an original state of grace." He elaborates that he, thereafter, "Developed the notion that man had fallen from a tree." A fundamental example of childhood speculations, this notion establishes a succession of further speculations, that would continue until late in his life. In valiant attempts to understand reality, Norman derives not answers but questions, not solutions but further enigmas. Every time a seed of speculation is planted, a flower blossoms which sprays even more seeds of speculation. As illustrated in Norman's fishing trip with Paul, when he remarks, "It is interesting that thoughts about fishing are often carried on in dialogue form [in which] Hope and Fear try to outweigh each other." This analysis of fly-fishing, reflects the conflicting perspective through which Norman views life. This perspective consists of juxtaposed ideas and interpretations.They plague his thoughts, emotions, and assumptions, often resulting in rational inefficacy. Norman is thus held captive within his cocoon of speculation, by the conjectures that he produces. .
Norman begins to realize his consistent analyses are holding him back. While fishing with Neal and Rawhide later that day, Norman departs from the group. He fishes by himself, only to discover a peace in the river he had never known before. As he concludes his fishing, he "[sits] there and [forgets] and [forgets], until what [remains is] the river that [goes by] and I who watch; Eventually, the watcher join[s] the river, and there was only one of us.