(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Needham


            It is a unanimous agreement amongst more than most scholars that China and the Chinese civilization was the most advanced and powerful civilization during pre-modern times. Therefore it comes as a surprise to many who study China's history, that despite having a major lead over other "competing" civilizations; China was not the one who started industrialization. Why this is not the case has been an intriguing question that has, over the years, plagued many scholars who have been unable to find, and may never be able to find a clear and definite answer. Nevertheless, there has not been anything to stop valiant attempts to crack the question that is now commonly referred to as Needham's Puzzle. Such high curiosity in the Puzzle has spawned quite a number of feasible theories and explanations as of to why China did not start industrialization. Some of the these theories include the "High-Level Equilibrium Trap" by Mark Elvin who focused on unfavorable man-to-land ratio, and also others who focused more on geographic, governmental, economic, agricultural, and/or other reasons. .
             The main theory or reason that I tend to consider myself attached to or associated with is that of the "modified" hypothesis presented by Justin Yifu Lin in his article titled "The Needham Puzzle: Why the Industrial Revolution Did Not Originate in China". Lin's argument basically consists of three parts. The first part supports why China was "probably the most cosmopolitan, technologically advanced and economically powerful civilization in the world [by the fourteenth century]" (Lin, 270). He explains that economic and industrial growth is dependent on technological innovation which is in turn dependent on experimental science. Thus the return rate of technological innovation in this "trial and error" type approach in science depended on the size of the population. Lin claims that as China had larger population size than that of Europe's in pre-modern eras, it made sense that technological innovation in China was accelerated in comparison (helped Chinese civilization to become more powerful and influential).


Essays Related to Needham


Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question