(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Summary of "Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Exper

            In "Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers," Nancy Sommers uses a case study to show what student writers and experienced writers do when they write and then revise. Twenty freshman from Boston University and the University of Oklahoma (the student writers) and twenty experienced adult writers from the same areas each wrote three essays. They rewrote each essay twice. Their writing and revising strategies were then analyzed.
             The study found that student writers do not have the strategies for dealing with the whole essay. The student writers do not use the terms "revision" or "rewriting." They explained that "revision was not a word they used, but the word their teacher used" (78). There is more concentration on the words and vocabulary instead of the ideas. When revising, the students scratch out and do over, review, re-do, and slash and throw out words. Cleaning up speech was a main concern because "unlike speech, writing can be re-read," and students do not want to be repetitive (78). Substituting or deleting words eliminates repetition, but the students do not change any problems with their ideas. Student writers also use their thesis as a control. This restricts them while they are developing their ideas and also makes it hard to change some of their ideas. They stop revising when they "have not violated any of the rules for revising" (80). They concentrate more on the rules rather than their ideas. The strategies used by the students are based on what their former teachers taught them. They did not learn the skills for revising. .
             The experienced writers have a different outlook on revising. Revising was defined using the terms "rewriting" and "revising". Experienced writers see revising as a process with many steps. Each step has a different objective. The main objective for experienced writers is finding the "form or shape of their argument" (81). Expressions like finding "a pattern" or "a design" were used (81).


Essays Related to Summary of "Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Exper

1. Vision For Revision Assignment

The final stage of composing an essay is the revision process. ... However, revision is in fact the most crucial stage in writing. ... According to The Student Writer Canadian Edition, there are four sound procedures one can use to revise their work. ... Word has also made revision effortless, feedback easy to attain, as the review tab provides the writer with feedback and comments neatly placed throughout the document. ... Last, but certainly not least, you must have a vision for revision. ...

  • Word Count: 1351
  • Approx Pages: 5
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: High School

2. Sample Course Syllabus - English

The course offers instruction in writing processes, collaborative writing strategies, methods of organization, research skills, discourse conventions of Standard Written English, rhetorical strategies, computer-based writing, and the production of expository academic essays. ... Related Objectives • consider audience and conduct audience analysis • use effective annotation of essays and note-taking strategies • engage in brainstorming, outlining, and drafting strategies • write multiple drafts • revise, edit, and proofread drafts • evaluate the...

  • Word Count: 6229
  • Approx Pages: 25
  • Grade Level: High School

3. Academic Literacy

(Hocking & Fieldhouse, 2011) Characteristics of an academically literate student are obtained through repetitive practice of all the elements involved in writing, and are attained from a combination of different learning strategies (Baines, 2008); allowing the student to excel in their writing at a higher caliber than others. ... They look at the source writer scope for main topics, claims and concepts. Looking at the structure and citations the writer has used will allow them to check credibility and use their cited references to find other relevant material for their research. ... Common gra...

  • Word Count: 749
  • Approx Pages: 3
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

4. Notes on a College English Course

Some really high scores allows students to skip certain courses in college. ... In "Shitty First Drafts," written by Ann Lamott, she explains the role of any writers' first draft. ... In " Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers," by Nancy Sommers, the writer explains how students react to the word revision. Sommers says, "most of the students I studied did not use the term revision or revising they did not seem comfortable it was not a word they used" (Nancy Sommers). ... The first goal states to help students understand the ways ...

  • Word Count: 1099
  • Approx Pages: 4
  • Grade Level: High School

5. The Art of Summarizing

The authors highlight two summarizing styles; one solely based on a writer's points of view and the others merely mention what the original writers instead of putting his or her own voice in the summary. To write a really good summary, a writer must play a "believing game ", which suspends his own belief for a time and put him in the shoes of someone else. Otherwise, a writer might produce a summary with his own unfair presumption instead of what really expressed in the original author's view. ... When we read a good summary of Zinczenko's article, a writer not only mentioned a...

  • Word Count: 492
  • Approx Pages: 2
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

6. Diving In: The Fault in My Technique

It is a writer's chance to pinpoint their flaws and fix them. ... They push and guide the writer smoothly through the writing process. ... Revision and editing are very much similar, important changes can be made during both. Though revision is the stage during the writing process where the writer can critically review what they have written. ... The revision and editing stages together pose a major weakness in my skills as a writer due to my lack of effort during the planning stage. ...

  • Word Count: 1063
  • Approx Pages: 4
  • Grade Level: High School

7. Summary of Article

The article A Strategy for Previewing Textbooks: Teaching Students to become Thieves, written by Suzanne Liff Manz, is a very enlightening article describing a very creative way to get students interested in reading in a more productive way. ... Each letter in the word thieves represents a part of the reading selection, title, headings, introduction, every first sentence, visuals and vocabulary, end of chapter questions, and the summary. ... Manz states in the article that this strategy can be used as either a brainstorming activity, by writing the acronym on the board and listing the el...

  • Word Count: 325
  • Approx Pages: 1
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

8. Student-Led Conferences and Minority Student Achievement

Abstract The purpose of this study is to evaluate the impact of student led conferences on minority student achievement. ... The key research questions will focus on what parental involvement strategies are being implemented in middle schools. ... All data will help identify how student-led conferences and parental involvement strategies are currently being implemented to promote parental involvement in the school and the impact these strategies have on minority student achievement. ... Table of Contents List of Tables iv Table 1 A Sample Table Showing Correct Formatting 52 iv List of Figur...

  • Word Count: 9089
  • Approx Pages: 36
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

9. Advantages Of Teaching Writing As A Process

Teaching writing as a process involves frequent revision and internal feedback(Murray.) ... While this approach could be suicidal from a workload and time perspective, the point given is that revision and feedback is necessary for quality compostion. By waiting to grade until after revision and feedback has occurred, the teacher is ensuring the student has enough time to work out flaws and consult others on problems. ... By meeting face to face with a student writer, the instructor and the student can better articulate questions. ... One instructor notes that errors are not always bad as t...

  • Word Count: 1456
  • Approx Pages: 6

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question