Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Reasons for Doubt in Descartes' First Meditation

 

Descartes then recognizes that everything he knows, he has come to know through the senses. Therefore, he begins to question the accuracy of sensory perception as an epistemological method, and he presents his first reason for doubting his beliefs. The Meditator acknowledges that sometimes his senses can deceive him when they are not being used in optimal conditions. For example, his perceptions of an object that is either very small or very far away may be inaccurate because he cannot clearly and distinctly perceive the object at hand. Descartes then argues that although his senses may deceive him sometimes, this is not sufficient evidence to doubt all of his sensory beliefs. Under optimal conditions, The Meditator finds that he can believe his sensory perceptions to be true and trustworthy. Therefore, he can doubt his senses under poor conditions, but decides he cannot entirely dismiss his sensory perception as a way to form knowledge.
             In his second argument, however, Descartes begins to even doubt his sensory perception under optimal conditions when he considers what happens when he is dreaming. The Meditator realizes that while he is asleep and dreaming, he perceives objects with the same sense of reality as if he were awake. Even though he is dreaming, his senses and perceptions appear to be completely real and convincing. Therefore, his senses can clearly deceive him at any given time and under any given condition. Descartes asserts, "When I think this matter over more carefully I see so clearly that waking can never be distinguished from sleep by any conclusive indications that I am stupefied (Descartes 14)." The Meditator finds that he cannot clearly differentiate between his dreaming and waking states, which gives him reason to doubt all of his senses, even under optimal conditions. After presenting this argument, he goes on to claim that his perceptions in his dreams appear to be so real because while sleeping, he draws on perceptions and beliefs that he has come to know in his waking life.


Essays Related to Reasons for Doubt in Descartes' First Meditation