Jewett also shows this when Sylvia becomes "horror-stricken" at "a boy's whistle" that is "determined, and somewhat aggressive" (623). She feels that a bird's whistle is friendly, and isn't at all alarming. Finally, Sylvia shows her apprehension in the fact that even though she has lost her initial fear of the young hunter; she follows behind him, rarely speaking. She only speaks to him after he speaks to her; "there was no such thing as speaking first. The sound of her own unquestioned voice [terrifies] her" (626). So, while Sylvia is completely comfortable with her wooded surroundings and all of the animals, she is quite fearful and shy when it comes to encounters with anything and anyone from the busy, outside world. .
Sylvia's affinity for nature makes her very nurturing. Her grandmother says, "There ain't a foot o' ground she don't know her way over, and the wild creatures count her one o' themselves." She also tells the hunter that if she doesn't keep watch on her, Sylvia will forgo her own meals, just so she will have enough to feed to the birds. Feeding the birds and squirrels is so important to Sylvia because she feels such a kinship or emotional bond with them. Jewett also shows Sylvia's nurturing nature in how she reacts to the family cow. Although the cow is stubborn and likes to hide from Sylvia, she shows great patience when dealing with her. The cow is her playmate, and Sylvia spends hours wandering the woods with her.
Being only nine, Sylvia shows considerable maturity for her age. In 1886, when this story was written, life was much different than today. Sylvia lives out in the woods, and most of the people that she encounters are other farmers from the region. When she comes upon the hunter, and he asks her if he can stay the night at her house, she knows to be alarmed. She worries that "her grandmother [will] consider her much to blame.