In his famous article "Evil and Omnipotence," J. Mackie scathingly criticizes the belief that God can be both omnipotent and wholly good. My paper will evaluate the validity of the paragraph that begins "First I should query" The paragraph specifically deals with God's failure to eradicate evil while preserving our free will. Mackie argues that God's failure reveals the logical incompatibility between His omnipotence and His omnibenevolence. Mackie's argument is formulated as follows:.
1. If God is omnibenevolent, He would prefer men to choose good, as He preserves their free will.
2. If God is omnipotent, He has the ability to make men consistently choose good, as He preserves their free will.
3. If He wants to and is able to make men choose good over evil, men should always choose good.
4. But men do not choose good sometimes.
5. Therefore, God cannot be both omnipotent and omnibenevolent. .
The first premise is self-explanatory in that the word omnibenevolence means preferring good and rejecting evil. Mackie places emphasis on the second premise. He believes that the fact God allows men to freely choose good on some occasions proves His capability to make them do so on every occasion. According to Mackie, since God already let men freely choose the good occasionally, "there is no logical impossibility in a man's freely choosing the good on every occasion." The third premise unites the two premises above and states that men must always choose the good, given God's willingness and ability to eradicate evil while preserving men's free will. The fourth premise indicates that men do not choose good sometimes and overturns the third premise. With the overturned premise, Mackie concludes that God cannot be both omnibenevolent and omnipotent.
The argument above not only is logically valid, but also seems to be convincing at first glance. With some scrutiny, however, one can find a logical incompatibility in the second premise.
For hundreds of years, philosophers and intellects have pondered over the question of "Why do bad things happen to good people?" Most of history's great philosophers have stumbled upon this question at one time or another in their writings. J. L. Mackie was no different, and in his writing of...
Argument In the essay, "Evil and Omnipotence" John L. ... Mackie begins his argument by relating physical evil to pain. ... This objection then proceeds to the problem with two different types of freedom. ... The problem with them is that although well though out, they can not be proven by simply using Mackies methods. ... I strongly agree with this objection, if one can visualize a place where no evil exits then there should be a place without any evil. ...
If this argument were a beautiful young lady, my roommates and I would consider her to be suffering from the Barbie Syndrome - Nice exterior, hollow interior. ... Yet, if this were the only objection Teleology would fair rather well. ... Looking at this argument from St. ... Finally, as noted earlier the Ontological argument is an a priori argument. ... In argument form, he states, 1. ...
Anselm‟s Ontological Argument is certainly one of the most famous arguments in the history of philosophy. ... In this paper, I will briefly present the Ontological Argument and will demonstrate prominent objections made by Gaunilo, Malcolm, and Craig and Moreland to evaluate the validity and soundness of the Anselm‟s Argument. ... Objections Gaunilo was the first philosopher who argues against the Anselm‟s argument with his commonly known the "Dream Island" objection. ... The other common objection is that existence is distinct to any other property of perfection and that exis...
Jackson is most known for his argument against physicalism, and for a version of dualism called epiphenomenalism. ... Jackson uses a few examples to back his knowledge argument. In examining Jackson's experiments, they seem logical and persuasive to his argument, but there is an explanatory gaps in Jackson's responses to objections to his theory which I find troubling. ... The issue arises when Jackson responds, poorly in my opinion, to some common objections to epiphenomenalism. ... The second objection that Jackson responds to has to do with Darwin's theory of evolution. ...
The Chambers of a Mans Mind In the poemThe Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock,? T.S. Eliot portrays Prufrock as being a lonely, insignificant man who has imprisoned himself within the chambers of his mind. Prufrock lacks confidence, has no conviction, and wastes his time in neurotic ...
Cloning Imagine the world where everything was doubled, or tripled. There's a newly developed technology that can allow doctors and scientists to duplicate living organisms. This development in technology is known as cloning, and it has forever changed the views of life. Cloning can serve as the...